New York’s Largest Battery Project Has Been Canceled

 The biggest battery project in New York has been canceled in a major victory for the nascent nationwide grassroots movement against energy storage development.

It’s still a mystery why exactly the developer of Staten Island’s Swiftsure project, Fullmark Energy (formerly known as Hecate), pulled the plug. We do know a few key details: First, Fullmark did not announce publicly that it was killing the project, instead quietly submitting a short, one-page withdrawal letter to the New York State Department of Public Service. That letter, which is publicly available, is dated August 18 of this year, meaning that the move formally occurred two months ago. Still, nobody in Staten Island seems to have known until late Friday afternoon when local publication SI Advance first reported the withdrawal.

Second, Swiftsure was going to be massive. It was the largest planned battery storage project in New York State, according to public records, with the ability to store upwards of 650 megawatts of electricity — enough to power more than half a million homes. That makes Swiftsure likely one of the largest battery projects in the country, with more capacity than any other energy storage project currently facing opposition in the U.S., according to our very own Heatmap Pro database. This is the second Fullmark project to totally flop in recent months. We reported last week that one of the company’s projects outside of Los Angeles had its permits voided in a court ruling that also blocked battery storage development in unincorporated areas outside the city.

Third, and potentially most significant for energy developers in New York City: Swiftsure’s death will almost certainly embolden the anti-storage activist movement.

Curtis Sliwa, the Republican nominee in next week’s New York mayoral election, was one of many local politicians who opposed Swiftsure and rallied with residents close to the proposed site in May. He’s part of a broader trend of Republican politicians becoming skeptical of battery storage sites near where people live and work, including in Democrat-ruled New York.

Putting batteries in the five boroughs has always been a challenge, but January’s Moss Landing battery fire in California created a PR frenzy in the city, as conservative figures seized on the online panic created by the blaze. Once-agnostic GOP members of Congress from New York City are now anti-battery storage in their backyards, including Anthony D’Esposito, Nicole Malliotakis and Mike Lawler. Trump’s Environmental Protection Agency administrator, Lee Zeldin — a former NYC congressman — is now weighing in against individual battery projects on Long Island and Staten Island.

Swiftsure was proposed in 2023 and permitted by the state last year. Fullmark was given a deadline of this spring to submit routine paperwork demonstrating how it would comply with conditions of the site’s permit, including how the battery storage project would be decommissioned. In August, the New York Department of Public Service gave Fullmark an extension until October 11.

Instead of meeting that October deadline, it seems Fullmark quietly withdrew its Swiftsure proposal.

It’s unclear how Democrat Zohran Mamdani or independent Andrew Cuomo would handle the rise of the anti-battery movement if either of them wins the November 4 mayoral election. That’s partially because energy policy and climate change have been non-issues in the campaign, saving small mentions of nuclear power, heat pumps, or gas prices in one-off debate answers or social media posts.

Sliwa, who has referred to Swiftsure as a “mini Chernobyl,” told me that he anticipates this victory will lead to more protests at more battery sites, no matter who wins the mayoral election. “The cancellation of this lithium-ion battery warehouse will reverberate throughout the boroughs,” GOP mayoral candidate Curtis Sliwa told me Monday. “It’ll be a rallying cry [because] it’s not a fait accompli that these facilities will be complete and operational.”

The Mamdani and Cuomo campaigns did not respond to requests for comment on Swiftsure’s cancellation.

SCOOP: New York’s Largest Battery Project Has Been Canceled - Heatmap News

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Comment Acknowledgement for Matter Number - 21-00749 : Msg. Tracking No.: 58

  Noise from Cassadaga June 26 LEAF OFF RSG Report . Case # 14-F-0490 DMM 891. Cause1 - icing remedy was to shut down turbine.  Please note shut down is required. A new software detection was added. Cause2  -inflow turbulence due to close configuartion of multiple turbines. Wind WAKE? Under its Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need (“Certificate”), the 126 MW Cassadaga Wind project (“Project”) is required to conduct post construction sound monitoring to assess compliance with specified noise limits. Sound monitoring was initially conducted during the 2021/2022 “Leaf-Off” season. This found that the Charlotte Town noise standard was exceeded around the Nordex wind turbines during certain periods when the blades were iced. In 2022, Cassadaga Wind took steps to implement mitigation to shut down certain wind turbines when icing was detected. The Project was retested in the 2022/2023 Leaf-Off season. During that monitoring period, one hour at monitoring lo...
Read more

Fort Drum eyed as site for nuc plant

  FORT DRUM, New York (WWNY) - The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has determined a small nuclear reactor would be “the optimal option” to supply Fort Drum’s energy needs. Governor Hochul and state officials met with Fort Drum officials and discussed the possibility of locating a “small modular reactor” on Drum when the governor visited Drum in August, 7 News learned. If a “small modular reactor” (SMR) is successful on Drum, additional reactors might be deployed throughout the state to help New York meet its renewable energy goals. Small modular reactors are, as their name suggests,  much smaller than traditional nuclear reactors, like the ones near Oswego . They also incorporate newer generations of nuclear technology. Proponents argue they are safer and far less costly than traditional nuclear plants. Drum needs about 60 megawatts of power. Since a biomass plant on post which burned wood closed in 2023, Drum has been forced to draw its energy off the regular power grid, the one...
Read more

Why Spain’s Rooftop Solar Owners Weren’t Spared From the Blackout

Image
  When the electricity  suddenly went out in Spain  on Monday, Irene Casas and her husband Luis Morate, who live in an apartment building in a Madrid suburb, lost power along with everyone else. That’s despite the fact that they, along with their neighbors,  own a source of electricity : 200 rooftop solar panels installed at the end of 2023. The panels didn’t help them ride out the blackout because they are connected directly to the grid. Each co-owner, including Casas and Morate and their neighbors, gets a discount on their utility bill in exchange for the power they put into the electricity network, but the panels themselves don’t directly supply their apartments with energy. Casas and Morate’s experience goes against what many people would consider conventional wisdom: Solar on your roof provides energy independence. Yet, that’s not always the case. “On principle, solar panels give us power during the day, but in reality we are connected to the grid like everyone ...
Read more